Home » Featured, Food & Drink

Pyrex explosion!

22 September 2009 3,381 views 6 Comments

This is no less than 1/8 of the blue Pyrex dish that exploded when I tried to add water to it while it was still very hot from continuous, direct heat.

Pyrex Explosion

See, I should’ve learned my lesson a few years ago when I witnessed how a mere touch of cool air made the glass door of my parents’ oven explode all over the kitchen. My dad taught me this, and I learned it in physics class: tempered glass shatters entirely and abruptly when breaking, unlike regular glass, which will break in shards and more gradually.

Extreme temperatures or stress can shatter and entire object made of tempered glass. At least, that’s what I learned. Contrary to what I did tonight, you’re not supposed to use it on the stovetop or in the broiler. The funny thing is that I knew this — but I completely forgot while using a makeshift system to steam my puto (no, not like the Spanish profanity, but the Filipino cake). See, I knew better — I knew I was doing something wrong — but it didn’t strike me that I was supposed to use a tin, not a Pyrex dish, on the stove top when improvising a steamer. Instead, I watched the dishes carefully, up until the water ran out of the Pyrex dish and I tried to add more water — as soon as I tipped the Pyrex measuring cup and began to pour water, I knew I’d made a mistake. Before I could do anything about it, the Pyrex dish burst.

I was really, really lucky I didn’t get hurt. I was really lucky that my face was not injured. I was really lucky that although I found glass shards in my shirt and cardigan, none of it had hurt me.

As my housemate and I were cleaning it up, I explained to him what I’d learned. He didn’t seem to understand what I had said, so I was nearly convinced that maybe I was wrong about the vaguely scientific explanation I’d blurted out. But like any good modern-day researcher, I turned to Google.

After the cleanup, I hopped online to see just what I could turn up about exploding Pyrex dishes. I remember that after my parents’ oven door exploded, I learned from my dad that even though tempered glass is technically stronger than regular glass, it can still be rather dangerous. Was I wrong? After a bit of searching, I found one poorly-written Consumerist article that blamed an exploding Pyrex dish on what type of material is now being used for Pyrex; I’m not sure I buy that as the sole reason for a Pyrex dish to explode, and I’m sure it could be a contributing factor, but I believe that it’s more about how tempered glass reacts to temperature, not the kind of material used in making it. Furthermore, according to this source, colored dishes are more susceptible to breaking than clear Pyrex dishes. Okay, maybe. But if we believed everything we found on the Internet, then Jeff Goldblum and George Clooney both died in tragic falls in New Zealand while filming on location…

Unsatisfied, I dug around a bit more and found a better explanation that did not include the soda-lime factor in why Pyrex dishes break. (On top of that, it jives with what I vaguely remember from physics class and my dad’s little lesson tempered glass: extreme temperature change can cause Pyrex to ‘explode’.) I’m inclined to go with that one. I’m no scientist, and while I did well in Advanced High School Physics, I can’t say for sure that it’s what happened. However, I’m pretty confident that this is the closest and most accurate explanation.

Have you seen Pyrex explode? What were you doing that caused it to explode? And why do you think it explodes?

Personally, I think it’s a bullshit excuse to blame the manufacturer entirely when something like this happens. They tell us not to use it on a stove top. They warn not to use it in a broiler. If people paid attention in physics, maybe they’d understand the properties of tempered glass. (Hey, there are a lot of “if people paid attention…” lines out there, mind you.) I’m not saying that Pyrex is made perfectly — it certainly isn’t, and I’m sure apparent cheap manufacturing contributes — but if you do something you’ve been warned should not be done, don’t you dare think it wasn’t your own stupid fault.

  • Jen Marcoullier

    Hmmm, interesting. About 10 years ago, I had a pink Pyrex pan explode when I added room temperature beef broth to an already cooking (and very hot) roast. I didn’t take the pan out of the oven, just pulled the rack out a bit and poured in the broth, then BOOM. Not sure if that contributed. Since then I’ve only had clear Pyrex and no explosions. (I take the pans out of the oven and try to warm up any liquids I’m adding.) I’ve heard that small cracks in Pyrex can make it susceptible to explosions, also that extreme temperature changes will do the same thing.

  • http://sovietinvasionplan.com Willi Vanilli

    eek! although the line “steam my puto (no, not like the Spanish profanity” made me LOL.

    methinks thermal stress is the term you’re looking for (not nucleation as i first suspected – although that’s fun too – and a mythbusters epsiode at that (the fork in the water)).

    http://www.newton.dep.anl.gov/askasci/eng99/eng99303.htm

    extreme temperatures can shatter any glass – tempered or otherwise. glass itself is filled with gabillions of little cracks, so the whole hot-to-cold thing really messes with it’s mind.

  • http://sovietinvasionplan.com Willi Vanilli

    Oh, and Jeff Goldblum is dead. He was trying to perfect teleportation and got locked into the chamber with a common household fly. It went downhill from there.

  • http://babydoll34420@yahoo.com melanie russell

    today dec 5th 2009 my fiance had the same thing happen to him one dish exploded in the oven and when he opened the door the second dish exploded in his face leaving fragments of glass in his face and arm this is not good please call the comphany of this matter i did 1-800-999-3436 push the number that says to order we have to get the word out this is dangerous melanie

  • http://www.dishpottery.com/ China Pottery

    Wow, great story. I just now stumbled on your blog and I am already a fan. :P

  • Rross-2

    I've decided that I will never use pyrex again after my experience on Sunday. My first attempt to make a sweet potato pie from scratch ended up a major waste of my time and effort. The pie was baking in a 375 degree oven in my new pyrex pie pan. The pan was in the oven on a baking sheet to prevent spills. After 50 minutes the pie was taken out of oven and sitting on top of my stove to cool slowly-no extreme temperatures here. Ten minutes later I heard a loud noise from my bedroom. It sounded like something large fell from a high shelf. Found out the pie pan had shattered and there was glass all over the top of my stove, counter, and some on the floor. Luckily, no one was in the kitchen when this occurred. Found out through various computer websites including consumer affairs that this has happened many times. I don't think that C.A. is taking this seriously enough. One should not have to worry about exploding and embedded glass when using these products. I agree with Melanie, this product can be very dangerous!